“If you look across any major city’s newest development, you will likely see some version of the same formula,” Erin Saven, director of real estate strategy practice at Gensler’s New York office, wrote in a Nov. 3 Commercial Observer column. That formula – office, apartments, retail, a hotel and a plaza – is familiar because it works.
But does sticking to a formula make a district succeed? The places that last give people a reason to come back on a Tuesday, not just a Saturday.
Here’s what works in the suburban formats most Americans visit every week, and what it means for the mixed-use districts being planned across the U.S. and Canada.
Start with the weekly trip, not the weekend trip
The strongest anchor in any district is the one people need, not the one they visit once a season. In suburban retail, that’s the grocery store. A shopper who comes for groceries once or twice a week is the same person who stops for coffee, drops off dry cleaning and books a haircut next door.
Many mixed-use plans start with the experience: the food hall, the plaza and the boutique fitness studio. Those matter, but they work best on top of a base of daily needs. Before picking the “destination” tenants, ask what will bring a resident or office worker onto the site three times a week. That might be a grocer, a pharmacy, a medical office, a day care or a gym. Lean on the lesson from grocery-anchored centers: Necessity drives frequency, and frequency builds a habit.
The data backs this up. Placer.ai, which tracks grocery foot traffic nationwide, reported that U.S. grocery visits rose 1.7% year over year in the first quarter of 2026, the fourth straight quarter of growth. Its New Tenant Mix Playbook found grocery visits grew 13.8% from 2019 to 2025, while apparel visits fell 24.7%. The average grocery shopper visits 2.4 times a month, twice as often as the average apparel or sit-down restaurant customer.
Even lifestyle centers are shifting. Grocery’s share of lifestyle center visits climbed from 14.0% to 15.6% over the same period, while apparel’s share dropped from 16.2% to 13.0%. As Placer.ai puts it, “Apparel has lost its traditional anchor role.”
Design for lingering
Lifestyle centers taught retail developers that time spent on-site is worth as much as square footage leased. The open-air format works because it feels like a main street, with sidewalks, storefront windows, shade, seating and a reason to walk past one more door.
The details that keep people around are small and easy to cut when the budget gets tight:
- Parking that leads into the public realm, not just up to a storefront
- Gathering spaces sized for a farmers market, a concert or a holiday tree lighting
- Restaurants with patios that face the plaza, not the parking lot
- Programming on a calendar, so the district has a heartbeat outside of shopping hours
Erin Saven, who directs Gensler’s New York office’s real estate strategy practice, builds on that idea later in the column, “The Mixed-Use District Has Evolved From Uses to Relationships.” Using Michigan Central, Ford’s 30-acre innovation district in Detroit, as her example, she argues that shared spaces should support the connections a district wants to build. In her words, “This shifts the role of the district from a collection of uses to a framework for relationships that can deepen over time.”
In a suburban district, those relationships are usually between neighbors, families and local businesses rather than startups and researchers. The design principle is the same.
Housing is the most reliable anchor of all
Apartments and townhomes inside or next to a retail district provide customers who never have to drive there. They also give the retail a morning and evening rhythm that a pure shopping center can’t create.
The relationship works both ways. Renters pay a premium to walk to dinner, the grocery store and the gym. Retailers get steady foot traffic. Office tenants get an amenity package they couldn’t build on their own, and that helps with recruiting.
The timing matters right now. The National Association of Realtors reports that the U.S. multifamily construction pipeline is at a decade low, while retail vacancy sits near historic lows.
This is part one of a two-part series. Check back to Market Share blog to read the second part on the mixed-use formula in action.
This post was created with the assistance of AI tools; all content was reviewed by the author.